For over 15 years, the footballing world has been captivated by the rivalry between Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo. The debate over who is the greatest of all time (GOAT) has fueled passionate discussions among fans, pundits, and even fellow footballers. As both legends approach the twilight of their careers, the question remains: Who has the edge in their final years, Messi vs Ronaldo? While their prime years were defined by breathtaking goals, jaw-dropping dribbles, and record-breaking performances in Europe, the latter stage of their careers has taken them to new leagues, new challenges, and new legacies. This blog will analyze their performances post-2022, including club choices, international success, individual awards, and the lasting impact on their respective legacies.
Club Careers in Their Final Years
Lionel Messi – Inter Miami & MLS Journey
After guiding Argentina to a historic 2022 FIFA World Cup victory, Lionel Messi made a surprising move to Inter Miami in Major League Soccer (MLS) in 2023. His departure from Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) marked the end of his European career, and he embarked on a new challenge in the United States.
Impact at Inter Miami
- Messi’s arrival in the MLS created an unprecedented surge in popularity for the league.
- He quickly made his mark by leading Inter Miami to its first major trophy, the Leagues Cup in 2023.
- In his first few months, he demonstrated his ability to dominate games, showcasing his vision, passing, and finishing.
However, the level of competition in MLS is notably lower than Europe’s top leagues. This raises questions about whether Messi is still competing at the highest level. Despite that, his presence in the U.S. has given the league global attention, making him arguably the most influential signing in MLS history.
Cristiano Ronaldo – Al-Nassr & Saudi Pro League Journey
Cristiano Ronaldo took a different path, leaving Manchester United in late 2022 after a controversial fallout with the club. He opted for a big-money move to Al-Nassr in the Saudi Pro League (SPL).
Impact at Al-Nassr
- Ronaldo’s move to Saudi Arabia opened the floodgates for other European stars to follow, increasing the league’s competitiveness.
- Unlike Messi, who joined a relatively weaker league, Ronaldo entered a more ambitious project in the SPL, where clubs are investing heavily in world-class players.
- He has continued to score prolifically, breaking records in Saudi Arabia and maintaining his status as an elite goal scorer.
Though the SPL has improved in quality, it remains far from Europe’s top leagues. However, Ronaldo’s determination to keep playing in a competitive environment rather than transitioning to a league with less physical demand shows his relentless work ethic.
Edge in Club Career: Messi’s move to MLS has given him a more relaxed playing schedule and global ambassadorial role, while Ronaldo has taken on a greater challenge in a rising league. If purely based on competition level, Ronaldo has the edge.
International Success: Who’s Ending on a Higher Note?
Lionel Messi – Argentina’s Inspirational Leader
Messi’s international career took a dramatic turn after years of heartbreak. His crowning moment came in December 2022, when he led Argentina to World Cup glory, cementing his place among football’s immortals.
Recent Achievements
- FIFA World Cup 2022 Winner & Golden Ball Winner
- Finalissima 2022 Winner (vs. Italy)
- Copa América 2021 Winner
- Top Scorer & Playmaker for Argentina
Even in his later years, Messi remains the focal point of the Argentina squad and could feature in the 2024 Copa América and possibly the 2026 World Cup. His leadership and playmaking ability ensure that he remains indispensable to the national team.
Cristiano Ronaldo – Portugal’s Everlasting Icon
Ronaldo, like Messi, has won major international silverware, including Euro 2016 and the 2019 Nations League. However, Portugal’s performance in the 2022 World Cup ended in disappointment, with Ronaldo being benched in key matches.
Recent Achievements
- All-time leading international goal scorer
- Euro 2016 Champion
- UEFA Nations League 2019 Winner
- Still a key figure for Portugal
Ronaldo remains Portugal’s talisman, and with Euro 2024 approaching, he has a chance to add one last major international title to his collection. Unlike Messi, however, his role in the national team is shifting due to his advancing age and younger talents emerging.
Edge in International Career: Messi has the edge due to his World Cup win, which Ronaldo lacks. However, Ronaldo’s consistent goal-scoring record keeps him relevant for Portugal’s future campaigns.
Individual Accolades: The Final GOAT Battle
In their late careers, both Messi and Ronaldo have continued to rack up individual honors.
Lionel Messi’s Recent Accolades
- 8th Ballon d’Or (2023) – A record-extending achievement
- Best FIFA Men’s Player 2023
- Golden Ball – 2022 FIFA World Cup
- Leagues Cup MVP (2023, Inter Miami)
Winning the Ballon d’Or in 2023 gave Messi another edge over Ronaldo in the individual award race. His World Cup win solidified his case for the greatest player of all time in many fans’ eyes.
Cristiano Ronaldo’s Recent Accolades
- All-time leading goal scorer in football history
- Top scorer in Saudi Pro League
- Most appearances in international football
- Multiple Player of the Month awards at Al-Nassr
While Ronaldo is no longer competing for Ballon d’Ors, his hunger for records remains unmatched. He continues to chase milestones that no other player has achieved.
Edge in Individual Accolades: Messi’s 2023 Ballon d’Or win puts him ahead, but Ronaldo still holds several records, ensuring his place in football history.
Legacy and Global Impact
Messi’s Legacy
- Considered the most naturally gifted footballer ever.
- His 2022 World Cup win settled the GOAT debate for many.
- His move to the MLS is shaping the future of football in the U.S.
- Holds the most Ballon d’Or wins (8).
Ronaldo’s Legacy
- The greatest goal scorer in football history.
- His influence in making the Saudi Pro League a global force.
- An unmatched work ethic and longevity.
- A role model for fitness and discipline in sports.
Edge in Legacy: Messi’s World Cup win gives him a strong claim as the GOAT, while Ronaldo’s records and influence in expanding football’s reach make his legacy unique. Ultimately, it depends on what one values more—team success or individual records.
Final Verdict: Who Has the Edge in Their Final Years?
Choosing between Messi and Ronaldo at this stage is difficult. Messi has the edge in terms of legacy due to his World Cup triumph and individual awards, while Ronaldo remains a force in a competitive league, breaking records and maintaining his elite fitness.
- If the GOAT debate is based on international success and trophies: Messi wins.
- If longevity, goals, and adaptability matter most: Ronaldo takes the lead.
- If influence on football’s future is the key factor: Both have changed the game in different ways.
Regardless of who comes out on top, both legends have left an unparalleled mark on football history. Their final years may not be in Europe, but they continue to inspire millions worldwide.
Who do you think has the edge in their final years, Messi or Ronaldo? Let the debate continue and ream more about baseball history!
